Restorative Justice Approach To Certain Criminal Actions With The Threat Of Under Five Years Prison In Functioning Criminal Law As Ultimum Remedium

Windy Rizky Putri, Erdianto Effendi, Zulfikar Jayakusuma


The purpose of this research is to find out the concept of criminal law renewal to place restorative justice as ultimum remedium in certain crimes with a prison sentence of under five years. This type of normative legal research with the type of legal synchronization. Collecting data on normative legal research uses data collection techniques from a literature study. In drawing conclusions the author uses the deductive thinking method, namely a way of thinking that draws conclusions from a general statement or argument into a specific statement. the results of research and discussion can be concluded. First; The restorative justice approach to criminal acts with the threat of imprisonment for under five years finds its footing in the basic philosophy of Pancasila, namely in accordance with the 4th precept of Pancasila "Deliberation to reach consensus". Currently, restorative justice has been regulated in various regulations/policies. The contents of this internal policy show that there is no uniformity in understanding and boundaries of criminal acts that can be resolved through restorative justice and does not create an Integrated Criminal Justice System. and the imposition of criminal sanctions on perpetrators


Restorative Justice, Criminal Crimes, Imprisonment for under years, Last Resort

Full Text:




Anwar , HAK Moch , 1989, Special Section of Criminal Law (KUHP Book II). Citra Aditya Bakti, Bandung .

__________________ , 2008, Penal Mediation : Settlement of Criminal Cases Out of Court , Pustaka Magister , Semarang.

Bondan, Gandjar L, 2011, Reparation and Victim Compensation in Restorative Justice , Collaboration Between the Witness and Victim Protection Agency and the Department of Criminology FISIP UI, Jakarta.

Dewi , DS and Fatahillah A. Gratitude, 2011, Penal Mediation: Application of Restorative Justice in Indonesian Juvenile Courts , Indie-Publishing, Depok.

Gopaster, Gary , 1993, Negotiation and Mediation: A Guide to Negotiation and Dispute Resolution Through Negotiations , Ellips Project, Jakarta a.

HL Packer, 1968, The Limits of Criminal Sanction, Stanford University Press, California .

Institute for Criminal Justice Reform, 2022, Opportunities and Challenges of Implementing Restorative Justice in the Criminal Justice System in Indonesia , ICJR, South Jakarta.

Karim, 2019, Arrangements for Settlement of Minor Crime Cases through Restorative Justice , CV.Jakad Media Publishing, Surabaya .

Mulyadi, Lilik , 2015, Penal Mediation In the Indonesian Criminal Justice System, Bandung , PT. Alumni, Bandung.

Prayitno Strong Puji, 2012, Application of the Concept of Restorative Justice in Indonesian Judiciary , Yogyakarta: Genta Publishing, Yogyakarta.

Purba, Jonlar , 2017 Law Enforcement of Mild Motive Crimes with Restorative Justice , Jala Permata Aksara, Jakarta.


Zehr , Howard, 2002, The Little Book of Restorative Justice , Good Books Intercourse, United State of America.


Aertsen , Ivo, et . al , 2011, “Restorative Justice and the Active Victim: Exploring the Concept of Empowerment”, Journal TEMIDA , Mart.

Chandra, Septa, 2014, "Legal Politics of Adopting Restorative Justice in Criminal Law Renewal", Fiat Justisia Journal of Law Studies Volume 8 No.2 April-June 2014, Faculty of Law, University of Muhammadiyah Jakarta.

Effendi, Erdianto , 2019, "Relations between Corruption and the Welfare State, Melayunesia Law , Vol.3 No.2 December 2019.

E, Sirande, et al, 2021, " Realizing Law Enforcement Through Restorative Justice " , Journal of Law and Notary Affairs , Vol 5, No.4, November 2021,

Flora, Henny Saida, 2017, "Restorative Justice Approach in Settlement of Criminal Cases in the Criminal Justice System in Indonesia", Journal of Law Pro Justitia Vol. II, No. 2 , Pelita Harapan University, Banten.

Iswara, I Made Agus Mahendra , 2013, " Mediation of Penal Application of Restorative Justice Values in Settlement of Balinese Customary Crimes " , Thesis , Master of Law Postgraduate Program, University of Indonesia, Jakarta .

Lanier, M and Stuart Henry, 2004, Essential Criminology, Second Edition, Westview, Colardo, USA, 2004. Stephanie Coward-Yaskiw, Restorative Justice: What Is It? Can It Work? What Do Women Think?, Horizon 15 Spring ), http :; See: Maek M. Lanier and Stuart Henry, Essential Criminology, Second Edition, Westview, Colorado, USA .

Lawalata1, Jesylia Hillary et al, 2022, " Restorative Justice Approach in Settlement of Narcotics Crime Cases at the Investigation Stage " , TATOHI Journal of Law Sciences Vol 2, No 1 of 2022 .

Wirajaya, AA Ngurah Bagus Krishna et al, 2022, " Minor Crimes Through Restorative Justice as a Form of Criminal Law Reform " , Journal of Legal Construction, Vol. 3, No. 3, 2022 .

INTERNET/WEBSITES , accessed on 18 December 2022 at 23.00 WIB. , accessed on 18 December 2022, 23.54 WIB , accessed, December 19, 2022, 00.06 WIB. Hukum-ringan-Come-ke-rumah-restorative-justice accessed December 19, 2022, 01.04 WIB , accessed, January 1, 2023, 09.00 WIB. , accessed, date, 6 February 2023, 16.15 WIB.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2023 Windy Rizky Putri, Erdianto Effendi, Zulfikar Jayakusuma

Melayunesia Law has been indexed by:

Melayunesia Law is an open access under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC-BY-SA license)